Warning Signs for Next Week’s Budget Numbers

Tuesday, January 17, 2017 at 9:11 PM by

January 18th UPDATE:  Sometimes it feels good to be wrong — like when the Packers outperform my pessimistic predictions and when new state revenue forecasts are stronger than I anticipated. So I’m very happy that the revised revenue projections released this afternoon by the Legislative Fiscal Bureau (LFB) are considerably better than I expected when I wrote our Jan. 17th blog post.  (Read more here.)

The new LFB numbers indicate that a combination of lower-than-expected spending and higher-than-expected tax revenue will be enough to maintain a comfortable budget balance in the current fiscal year, and also enough to fund the amounts requested by state agencies in the next biennium. That’s a huge relief after the very slow revenue growth from July through November, which suggested that the next estimate of revenue collections was likely to be down, rather than up. This year’s revised revenue collections are still below the level forecasted a year ago, but are now expected to be considerably stronger in the next biennium than the Department of Administration estimated in November.

In short, I’m happy to say that the latest figures look much better than what I feared yesterday, when I wrote the following blog post:

New state revenue estimates are due to come out next week, and we should probably brace ourselves for bad news. A number of signs suggest that the revenue projections to be released next week by the Legislative Fiscal Bureau (LFB) will  be reduced for both the current fiscal year and the 2017-19 budget.

A new report by the Wisconsin Budget Project examines the recent trends that point to ongoing economic and budget challenges. On the plus side, the report explains that the likely downturn in revenue projections will probably be partially offset by lower-than-expected Medicaid spending, but not by enough to keep a drop in tax revenue from exacerbating the state’s budget challenges.

The warning signs suggest that it will be difficult to find the funding for many of the spending initiatives and tax cutting proposals that the Governor and other lawmakers have suggested. If our fears are confirmed next week, state budget writers are going to have to choose between a controversial set of options: making deeper spending cuts, increasing borrowing, raising taxes, or closing tax loopholes.

The following are some of the factors that are likely to make it more challenging to balance the next budget:

State tax collections lag – Tax revenue fell $78 million short of the projected amount in the 2015-16 fiscal year, and that trend seems to be continuing. Tax collections grew by only 1.2 % during the first five months of this fiscal year, which is far short of what is needed to keep this year’s budget in balance. Although lower-than-anticipated growth in Medicaid spending could help keep this year’s budget in the black, the slow revenue growth in recent months suggests that there is likely to be a downward revision in the revenue projections for the upcoming biennial budget.


Transportation Fund shortfall approaches $1 billion – The recent Transportation Solvency Study by the state Department of Transportation found that even after efficiencies and savings, the state’s transportation funding needs exceed available revenues  by an estimated $939 million for the next biennium. Opposition to increasing the gas tax and transportation-related fees may cause policymakers to once again increase bonding – even though debt service is already 20 percent of the DOT budget – or to siphon more revenue for transportation from the General Fund.

UW System balances decline sharply — The last two biennial budget bills have compelled UW System campuses to spend down their “unrestricted” funds to dangerous levels. For the 2015-16 fiscal year, reserves and discretionary funds were merely 2.4% — or only about one-tenth the amount recommended by the National Association of College and University Business Officers. The sharp drop in their reserves severely limits their capacity to absorb additional budget freezes or cuts.

Meager state budget reserves – The dip in state tax revenue is likely to drain most of the meager budget balance that the state had hoped to carry over into the next biennium. On a more positive note, during the Governor’s first three years in office, lawmakers increased the state’s miniscule rainy day fund to $280 million, which was a long-overdue step toward fiscal responsibility. However, as a recent Wisconsin Taxpayers Alliance report noted, the state hasn’t added anything to that fund in the last three years, even as most other states have done so.

Demographic and workforce trends hamper state budget health – One of the key factors holding back state revenue growth is that the state economy has been growing much more slowly than expected. Although Wisconsin enjoys an unemployment rate of just 4.1%, our state’s job growth has lagged well below the national average. The Budget Project report explains that the low jobless rate at a time of lackluster job growth stems from a combination of factors, including little population growth, an aging populace, and a declining labor force participation rate.

Although there have been a few bright spots one can point to, most indicators of economic and fiscal health suggest that the new revenue estimates will be revised downward from the projections released in November. If that’s the case, it will be one more reason why state lawmakers should close some tax loopholes to generate the revenue needed for investments in critical areas like education that are essential for Wisconsin’s future economic health.

Jon Peacock

2 Responses to “Warning Signs for Next Week’s Budget Numbers”

  1. Jake formerly of the LP says:

    And now the LFB comes out today says revenues will be on the upside? Their analysis thinks the US will see 4.1% unemployment and 5 million new jobs by the end of 2019. And incomes up 5% a year? I know December’s figures were decent and put us back on track for the Nov 20 estimates, but a boom ahead? WHAT A LOAD OF CRAP!

    Keep on this, because as the reality of Drumpf’s disastrous presidency drives those estimates down, the next shortfall will appear. The real question is if it’ll happen by May’s second budget estimates, or if it happens by the 2018 elections.

  2. […] state tax collection numbers are considerably better than I expected when I wrote a very cautionary blog post about the next state budget a week or so ago. This is one of two recent occasions (along with my […]